TalkLive Journal
Conversation / A working list

Questions that get past small talk

"So, what do you do?" is the most asked and least interesting question in the world. Here is why it stalls, and what to ask instead.

The 45-minute experiment

In 1997 the psychologist Arthur Aron and colleagues published a study that has since become famous. Pairs of strangers took turns asking each other a set of 36 questions, in a fixed order, for about 45 minutes. The questions started light and became gradually more personal. Afterwards, the pairs reported feeling markedly closer than pairs who spent the same time on small talk.

The magic was not in any single question. It was in the structure: both people disclosed, in turn, and the depth rose slowly enough that it never felt like a leap. Each answer earned the next question.

Why "what do you do" stalls

Job questions invite a label, not a story. "I'm an accountant." Then what? Good questions have three qualities: they can't be answered in one word, they ask for a preference or a memory rather than a fact, and they give the other person a choice about how deep to go. "What's something you've changed your mind about recently?" can be answered with a film or with a worldview. The other person decides.

Two rules make any list work better. First, answer your own question too; a conversation where only one person discloses is an interview. Second, follow up. The list is a starting point. The best question is almost always a follow-up to the last answer.

Tier one: warm up

Light, easy, low risk. Good for the first few minutes.

  1. What did your day look like before this?
  2. What's something small that made you happy this week?
  3. What's the view from where you are right now?
  4. What were you obsessed with as a kid?
  5. What's a food you'd defend against anyone?
  6. What's a skill you'd learn instantly if you could?
  7. What's the best thing you've watched or read lately?
  8. Where would you go tomorrow if money didn't matter?
  9. What's a weirdly specific thing you're good at?
  10. Morning person or night person, honestly?

Tier two: open up

Opinions and stories. Use once there is some rhythm.

  1. What's something you've changed your mind about?
  2. What did you want to be at 15, and what happened?
  3. What's a place that feels like home that isn't your house?
  4. Who taught you something important without meaning to?
  5. What's a decision you're glad you made?
  6. What's a popular opinion you don't share?
  7. What would a perfect ordinary day look like for you?
  8. What do people often get wrong about you?
  9. What's something you're quietly proud of?
  10. What's the best advice you ignored?

Tier three: go deep

Only if the moment invites it. Always offer an easy out.

  1. What are you most grateful for right now?
  2. When did you last feel really understood?
  3. What's something you've never told most people?
  4. What would you do differently if no one were watching?
  5. What are you still trying to figure out?
  6. What scares you that you rarely admit?
  7. Who would you call first with great news, and why them?
  8. What does a good life look like to you?
  9. What's a memory you go back to when things are hard?
  10. What do you hope people say about you when you're not there?

Use with care

Deep questions are an invitation, not an obligation. If someone answers briefly, take the hint and step back a tier. And notice something odd about the Aron study: the strangers who felt closest were not the ones who were charming. They were simply the ones who took turns being honest. Which makes you wonder how many of the people you have made small talk with for years you have never actually met.